Every public RFP explains how it is going to score your proposal, but hardly anyone sits down and compares those pages across buyers, so we did it ourselves. We read 56 RFPs from NYC DDC, other New York agencies (the Port Authority, DASNY, NYCEDC, Battery Park City), Canadian federal buyers, Ontario and the rest of Canada, and we put each one in its own row so we could see what they have in common.
- ~70%of the final score is qualifications at NYC DDC
- 20–30%the usual price weight in Canada (the range is 10–50%)
- 75–80%minimum on each criterion at the NRC and the NCC
- 56public RFPs read, one row each
You can see the weights, but you usually can’t see how points are given
Almost every RFP lists its criteria and their weights, although the Port Authority (RFP 58432) and some DASNY RFPs (RFP 7613) only rank the criteria by importance without giving any numbers. What is much rarer is the scale evaluators use to turn a proposal into points, and only Canadian federal buyers (Parks Canada, the RCMP, Global Affairs, the National Capital Commission) and Quebec’s provincial guide publish one, for example a 0–10 scale where 6 means fully satisfactory and 10 means excellent (Parks Canada 5P201-17-5175), and none of the New York documents we read had one.
So when someone tells you what you would score on a particular RFP, it is really an estimate, because the weights are known but how a given evaluator reads the word “excellent” mostly is not.
Past projects and people decide most of the score
At NYC DDC, Stage 1 is key personnel (40%) and project experience (60%). Stage 2 keeps half of your Stage 1 score and adds approach (35%) and design, management, M/WBE and innovation (15%) (2025 architectural design RFQ_AD_85026P0001.pdf)), and when you add it all up, qualifications end up driving about 70% of the final score.
Elsewhere in New York, experience plus team makes up 50–75% of the score at most agencies, while Canadian and Ontario RFPs lean harder on approach and methodology, and Tay Valley’s work plan alone is worth 35 of 70 points.
Reference rules are strict, and every buyer’s are different
- “3 projects in 10 years”
- “5 in 7 years”
- “7 NYC projects in 5 years”
- “3 references no older than 3 years, completed by the proposed project manager”
- “within 20 years” for heritage work
To check these rules you need to know the date, value and role of every project your firm has done, and a folder of project descriptions isn’t enough because the rules test the facts around each project.
Pass/fail requirements come before the score
These requirements show up in almost every RFP, and if you miss even one of them your proposal isn’t scored at all.
- Licenses in a given state or province, sometimes two (a New Jersey PE for the Port Authority project manager).
- A minimum number of years of experience for each job title.
- Firm-size bands: at DDC a “Small” firm is 3–9 staff, and getting your headcount wrong can disqualify you.
- A local office (Winnipeg, or within 90 miles of New York City).
- Insurance amounts, a safety certificate (Alberta), a mandatory site visit, security clearance.
Many RFPs set a minimum for each criterion, not just the total
The NRC requires 75% on every criterion, the National Capital Commission 80% on each part, and RCMP Saskatchewan 60% on each and overall. One weak section can sink an otherwise strong proposal.
Price depends on the country
| Where | What the RFPs do |
|---|---|
| NYC DDC, Port Authority, DASNY | Quality only: the fee is negotiated after selection. |
| NYCEDC | The US exception: price is 30% of the score (Hunts Point RFP). |
| Canada | Price 10–50% of the score, mostly 20–30%, usually lowest price ÷ your price × the weight. |
| Quebec | A fixed formula, (score + 50) × 10,000 ÷ price, and no single criterion above 30 points (quality-criteria guide). |
Page limits decide what gets read
Whether an 11x17 sheet counts as one page or two depends on the buyer, résumés are usually outside the page count, and any pages over the limit are pulled out and not evaluated, so whatever is on them is wasted.
Traps to watch for
- Smiths Falls gives no credit for text copied from the RFP.
- RFPs sometimes contradict themselves: Port Colborne gives both 10 and 5 years for references, and Global Affairs gives both 100 and 30 pages.
- NYCEDC gives an M/WBE plan a score of zero if it falls below the goal.
- Almost no one gives interviews a weight, and the only exceptions we found were a Toronto school board (10 points) and Toronto Metropolitan University (20).
What we couldn’t see
Some of the details sit behind bidder logins: recent DDC minimums and Stage 2 RFPs are inside PASSPort, and Toronto, Peel and the larger Ontario cities keep their scoring behind bids&tenders logins. Three of the six DDC rows are management contracts rather than design, and some rows come from notices, award memos or Q&As instead of the full RFP, so please treat this as a reading of 56 documents and not as a picture of the whole market.
Frequently asked questions
Is price scored in US architecture and engineering proposals?
Mostly no, because NYC DDC, the Port Authority and DASNY choose on quality and negotiate the fee afterwards, and the one exception we found was NYCEDC, where price is 30% of the score.
How much does price count in Canadian A/E RFPs?
Between 10% and 50% of the score, and most often 20–30%, and it is usually worked out as the lowest price divided by yours, multiplied by the weight, although Quebec uses its own fixed formula.
What decides most of the score in an A/E proposal?
Your past projects and the people you propose. At NYC DDC, qualifications drive about 70% of the final score, and elsewhere in New York experience and team make up 50–75%.
Can a proposal be rejected before it is scored?
Yes, because pass/fail requirements such as licenses, years per job title, firm size, a local office or insurance are checked first, and if you miss one of them your proposal isn’t scored.